Redefining Fitness: Part 1 — Weights
19
April
6 days a week, at least an hour a day. If you add in the time you spend in the locker, the chit-chat before, during, and after, the total time is closer to 90 minutes. I don’t pretend to be the busiest person in the world but do I have to spend 9 hours a week for bare minimum results? I’d rather be playing Ultimate, or just hanging with my friends. The sheer ridiculousness of this situation gets to me — toiling away at the gym while you are not getting much fitter, except in a very narrow modality. Nor are you getting much healthier, maybe a few notches above your present level but nowhere close to where you can go (“Keep it together, Arv”). The workout programme is usually composed of two basic parts — 3 days of machines and weights and 3 days of cardio.
Prescribing a bodybuilding routine as a one-size fits all recipe, that too for fitness goals — I am at a loss for words on this! Getting fit, getting strong, getting it to translate to a practical, functional, and useful improvement to your quality of life — doesn’t happen at most gyms. That’s why a redefinition is necessary. Let’s understand the problem first. In this series of posts, I want to make the case for why the fitness landscape is, well, lame. This post is about weights, the second post about cardio, the third about nutrition, and finally wrap it up with where we can go from here.
On to it then — three days of working with free weights and machines. On Monday, you work on your Chest and Biceps. A dumbbell bench press — flat, inclined, declined — coz hey, you want every muscle in every possible angle popping. Then hit that pec dec machine. On to some barbell curls, followed by some preacher curls. Then do some light tricep work by pulling that v-shaped rope — ooh, a rope — how quaint! And then some lying tricep extension. Maybe even give that forearm-thing-machine a go. About 3 sets of 10 reps, try to squeeze a few more here and there. On Wednesday, we work the Shoulder and Back. The Legs on Friday. Me personally — I’ve touched every machine there was in my gym. And on my first day, I overdid it to say the very least, that I had trouble getting out of bed the next day. I was told that was not unexpected, and I loved it.
Is this the most optimal way to improve your fitness levels? Or hey, maybe you dont care as much about fitness levels, and more about just your appearance — even then, this is very sub-optimal. It doesn’t give you much. But this is the recipe used all over the place.
- Single-joint, isolated movements leads to non-functional gains
- Does not translate into functional, usable movements in daily life
- Bench pressing under a Smith machine, for example, means you do not have to worry about keeping the bar balanced in one plane (as the machine does that for you). This causes you to lose form, not work your core muscles and stabilizers effectively. Multi-joint and multi-planar exercises are efficient — they use a lot of muscle groups!
- Causes muscle imbalance (more on this right below)
A prone leg curl + leg press, for example. Sure, you might be able to push 500+lbs on the leg press machine (strong quads), and your hamstrings are curling 120lbs. You are going to be dominant in one muscle (most probably quad-dominant).

Let’s compare that with a functional movement — like squatting. Check out this lady — doing something very natural and common. A lot of us are familiar with this but dont really squat much, especially with western toilets and well, chairs. But how many of you can do this today — with no sense of pain or struggle? I know quite a few of my friends who are quite active, who play sport multiple times a week — but cannot do this. The squat is a functional, multi-joint, multi-planar movement. The front squat, while focusing on your quads, will work your entire posterior chain of muscles, and also bring in to play your core (as you need to stabilize the body). The quads are assisted by the glutes and one of the calf muscles, while the hamstrings and the other calf muscles assist in joint stabilization. And about 14 other muscle groups help is maintaining balance, core integrity, and stability.
Talk about efficiency, talk about your entire body working in the way it is supposed to work — to perform a functional movement. That’s just freakin’ awesome! Does a leg press or hamstring curl have any functional relevance? Absolutely not! Forget having fun, forget hormone secretion, forget neuro-muscular adaptation — the exercises have no practical relevance. Having a workout programme designed solely with single-joint movements (the bench press is an exception) is pointless and your trainer is just clueless.
Personally, I like having fun at the gym, and looking badass. To me, that’s stuff like Oly lifting, box jumps, kettlebell swings, sled drags, sprints — not bodybuilding, not a chore you have to do!